I’ve been a TotalFinder user since 2012 and it has never disappointed me so far. I’ll be very happy as long as support for the current feature set is continued on future OS X releases, and I’m personally fine with disabling part of SIP. (Yes, I fully understand the tremendous difficulty of working with private APIs, monkey patching and stuff, and I fully understand sometimes breaking changes simply make certain things impossible. Cheers to you guys who have made it happen then kept it working over the years.) It’s awesome to have a new developer with equal passion for TotalFinder.
Rather than suggesting a new feature, the only minor annoyance for me in TotalFinder at the moment is the following: I have chosen to “automatically adjust widths in Column View” (one of the most important reasons I use TF), and limit maximum column width to 400px. Occasionally I would have some long filenames that exceed 400px, and they’ll be truncated; in this case I could double click the column divider (Right Size This Column) to show them in full. In stock Finder, this change would be retained until I navigate away from the resized directory. However, in recent versions of TF (ever since automatic resizing was fixed for El Cap, currently 1.7.12), the column will be resized to 400px every time the selection changes, even within the same directory. Presumably this is a side effect of the automatic resizing fix — the view seems to be refreshed (with widths recalculated) for all navigation moves.
The aforementioned problem happens rarely enough because I seldom have filenames that long. I probably should have reported a bug, but I never remembered to do so
I’m afraid I stopped using TotalFinder because I did not want to disable any part of SIP. If one day it works without having to disable SIP in OS X I will be back in a flash. Hope all ‘old’ users get an email when it is,
I too stopped using it because of SIP and some bugs that were starting to annoy me. I even started to write a total finder replacement. So if you could bring back Total Finder and I don’t have to replace it would be great! I also have been lost with out total spaces.
I would disable my screen to be able to keep using TF
It would be nice if it worked under SIP, but I just want it to keep working in some fashion under every future MacOS, so Steve’s addition is a welcome and hopeful sign of that.
My only feature request would be to extend the control of a column’s width to the List view, as well (where I spend 98% of my time.)
This is great news. I purchased both TF and TS the day before the announcement without knowing for sure if they had a future.
Like a couple other people have mentioned, it would be nice if “automatically adjust column widths” worked in List view. I only use List view.
Something that might be a little harder to implement would be making the tabs look native as opposed to Chrome style. Also hiding the tab when there is only one.
These 2 things are more important to me than making TF and TS working under SIP. I’m not sure I will ever enable SIP. Having root is too convenient.
I didn’t see any mention here of asepsis. Hope that continues to be supported as well. Thanks!
Something that might be a little harder to implement would be making the tabs look native as opposed to Chrome style. Also hiding the tab when there is only one.
I see the Chrome style as a plus, and I believe many people do. In fact, if you have ever tried XtraFinder (not sure if I’m allowed to talk about it here), Chrome-styled tabs is a feature, although its implementation is much worse than TF (it seems).
Of course, some folks might prefer the Safari style, but just want to point out the Chrome style is a pretty essential feature in itself too.
Personally I care about things looking native. I also use Safari. So having a mix of Chrome and Safari style tabs makes things look a little inconsistent.
But because some people do prefer Chrome-style tabs, I suppose it would have to be optional.
Yep, SIP will be fully enabled. You’re basically telling OS X very explicitly that you trust TF/TS by placing it in a special location. We have a technical version of these instructions now if you’re interested, but I’m working to make the process easier.
I haven’t used TotalFinder since El Capitan but would love to have it back.
I’m guessing like almost everyone I stopped using it because I didn’t want to manually go through the SIP process.
If this could be done automatically as part of the setup then I would use it again and even be happy to pay for the upgrade.
Steve, I too encourage you to continue to try to make TotalFinder work with El Capitan and follow on OS X releases. I am a paying user and happy with existing features. Just want it to work without having to disable security features. However, would it be possible to just put two Apple finder windows, with their side bars on the left, bonded side by side? The present TotalFinder window is wonderful, but having side bar on the left side of the right pane would be just fine with me.
Crax Commander gets a lot of good things, but it doesn’t have any right window sidebar.
That’s the plan, but in my view, TotalFinder & TotalSpace already do work with El Capitan.
At the moment, I think there’s both a message issue (the interpretation of supported) and a perception issue (how that message was interpreted by users).
Let’s look back prior to me taking over these apps. The message I was perceiving from BinaryAge regarding TF/TS on OS X 10.11 was that they could never claim 10.11 was fully supported.
I’ll explain what that means to me by way of example. SizeUp, another app I develop, currently states that OS X 10.6 is the minimum requirement, when it’s actually possible to run on OS X 10.5. I just say 10.5 is not supported because I don’t want to maintain a Mac running OS X 10.5 just for testing =P
So in developer parlance, saying that something is not supported or not fully supported doesn’t mean it won’t work, we just can’t guarantee it will work in the future. It’s a hedge against Apple pulling the rug out from under us and making apps like TF/TS 100% impossible to run. When the reality is, Apple just made it more difficult for users to install and run apps like TF/TS in OS X 10.11.
However, it seems the message customers perceived was that TotalFinder and TotalSpaces don’t work on OS X 10.11 and they’re not being developed further. That couldn’t be further from the truth. I’m trying to change this perception and reverse the momentum it has.
What do people think? Perhaps my view does not accurately reflect the situation.
I would like to hear more about this idea. Perhaps a graphical mockup would help. Maybe start a new topic?
Steve: I can’t get total spaces to work properly with three or two monitors. Reboots inconsistently reset all the spaces I’ve laboriously produced. Here’s my original post from Nov 14; now all my macs are using El Capitan latest version and I’d love to use total spaces again but I don’t want to waste time testing until I’m assured new total spaces will work on two or three monitors
thanks for the DisplaySpacesManager, stephen. I’m afraid I’m going to have to use it 'cause my desktop configurations are getting reset from time to time. I create 9 spaces on each of two screens, name them, then associate photos with each despise on each display, and frequently I find that when I wake from sleep or disconnect the laptop from the other screen the primary desktops seem to be okay but the secondary screen’s names are reset to Desktop 10, Desktop 11, etc. and all my photos are lost. This is very frustrating. I’ve saved the configuration using your application. The next time I find myself in the same situation I’ll try to Restore using your utility.
hawra = Randy Hawkins
